How to tackle the clerical abuse scandal.
[pdf-embedder url=”https://www.associationofcatholicpriests.ie/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/WAC-MTG-Marie-Collins-14-January-2019.pdf” title=”WAC MTG Marie Collins 14 January 2019″]
[pdf-embedder url=”https://www.associationofcatholicpriests.ie/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/WAC-MTG-Marie-Collins-14-January-2019.pdf” title=”WAC MTG Marie Collins 14 January 2019″]
Taken from La Croix International 31 Jan 2022 Synodality Virtues: avoid confusing language If we are to listen to one another in a synodal Church, then we will have to…
A human and honest response to the news of a cancer diagnosis, Dancing to my Death is Daniel O’Leary’s final book.
William Crean, Bishop of Cloyne, speaking to the priests of that diocese told them that in his recent teaching Pope Francis emphasises ‘that an effective Christian communion requires that we embrace the concept of Synodality in the everyday life of the Church. It is both the concept and reality of journeying with people. It is to trust in the “sensus fidei” ‘.
Bishop Crean also reminded his audience of the good done in the past by religious and priests but also stated ‘The long lens of hindsight enables us to identify the poor pastoral practice of many of our predecessors. Though well-intentioned a narrow moralistic focus made for a distorted and dysfunctional spiritual vision/understanding of Christian living. We live with both the riches and the baggage of our past.’
Australasian Catholic Coalition for Church Reform (ACCCR) Learning from the women of St Paul Kieran J. O’Mahony OSA (Augustinian) LaCroix International August 28, 2023 The real issue is hearing the…
A report in Global Sisters Report outlines grave discomfort being expressed by many in the Catholic church in the U.S.A. at the expressions of admiration for President Trump’s leadership by Cardinal Dolan. It would appear that many women religious are offering leadership on this issue.
” ….. while politicians look for votes by saying the right thing, a Christian has got to stand in the shoes of immigrants,” she paraphrased. “I expect that from our leadership — not this pandering to power.”
The Baftas and Joan Baez Martin McDonagh made his wry comment at the Baftas. ‘The Banshees of Inisherin’ won the ‘Outstanding British Film’ of the year. He said that Rosie…
It appears the expectations are already being managed…
https://cruxnow.com/news-analysis/2018/12/09/a-reality-check-on-expectations-for-february-child-abuse-summit/
The Bishops in America have received a good dressing down from the Pope. He writes
‘The Church’s credibility has been seriously undercut and diminished by these sins and crimes, but even more by the efforts made to deny or conceal them,”.
This is a full acknowledgement by the Pope of the crimes and cover ups that the hierarchy were involved in.
https://t.co/u0nr43fF66?ssr=true
We are only beginning to see the extent of the ‘crimes and cover ups’ that the American hierarchy were involved in.
https://t.co/a3yhUc6MO8?ssr=true
Watching the interviews with James Grein:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvYs6fo-HiE
https://taylormarshall.com/2019/01/197-mccarrick-pope-francis-st-gallen-mafia-w-james-grein-podcast.html
The St Gallen mafia, complete with Free Masons and Satanism, is a myth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Gallen_Group
The pope’s call for metanoia – change of mindset – is equally apposite for the Irish conference of bishops. It is a huge mistake to confine the question of accountability to child safeguarding. Contemporary culture is hugely dangerous for all of us – yet still there is no implementation of the Vatican II call for equality of dignity and open dialogue here. Archbishop Scicluna’s call to all bishops to become accountable to their own people is the only way forward – but who on the Irish bench of bishops is saying so?
As ever it is the Seamus Heaney protocol that reigns – the language known as Wyssn – whatever you say say nawthin.
This priest is ‘taking the road less traveled’.
“Keenly aware of the general absence of support from his fellow priests, Father Vignon does not spare his colleagues. “The truth is that many have got stuck and remained where they are,” he writes.
Bishops also cop a lashing in several passages of the book. “Bishops are past masters at the art of creating confusion,” he laments.”
https://international.la-croix.com/news/new-book-hits-out-at-french-bishops-over-sexual-abuse/9182
Phil – This is from John L Allen’s article in Crux that you link to:
While that comes off as a “no-brainer” for Americans and Western Europeans, places where in broad strokes one can trust the integrity of the police, it strikes prelates in places such as China, or India, or the Middle East – places where the police are often under the control of forces actively hostile to the Church – as handing your enemies another tool with which to destroy you, not to mention feeding a potentially innocent cleric to the wolves.
Expectations SHOULD indeed be managed and not only in places like China or the Middle East.
Do you recall the Irish politician who brought down a government in 1994 by suggesting that a Catholic Attorney General was in league with the Primate of All Ireland to protect a paedophile priest?
Do you recall another who demanded – and got – a year long Garda inquiry into claims the Catholic Church was involved in the murder of a young girl in 1970 (nearly 40 years before)?
Do you recall other prominent politicians who used Dail Privilege to repeat allegations against a former nun for which she received an apology and damages from the Sunday World?
https://irishsalem.blogspot.com/2017/10/justice-minister-charlie-flanagan-and_3.html
The Catholic Church is in a similar situation to Jews who live in a society where anti-Semitism is strong, where politicians will eagerly embrace ANY allegations of crimes and have no interest in identifying the false ones!
We should indeed “manage expectations”!
I hope you’ve all read Peter Steinfels’ analysis of the Philadelphia Report in Commonweal (it’s a bit like Padraig McCarthy’s “Untold Story” on the Murphy Report).
Despite Steinfels’ meticulous refutations, it’s the incendiary 12 pages preface to the Report, on which journalists relied, that will be remembered forever (like the babies thrown into septic tanks). In the midst of a witch hunt, priests and nuns are going like lambs to the slaughter, unable to defend themselves.
1. FR Joe. I have read Peter Steinfel’s long article in Commonweal and need to reread it together with related articles in America magazine and elsewhere. However before this thread goes off the front page of the ACP website I have an initial reaction.
Peter Steinfel summarises the Report’s conclusions by quoting from its Introduction
HOWEVER some of the examples he gives seem to undermine the “priests were raping” conclusion AS WELL. For example:
Of course this undermines the reports conclusion that “the men of God did nothing” but what about the credibility of the allegation against the late Father Martin Fleming? Does Mr Steinfel REALLY approve of the way the Bishop of Scranton casually thrashed the priest’s reputation?
I suspect that Steinfel’s references to Ulysses S. Grant and to Teddy Roosevelt are coded criticisms of the entire process. But it seems to be impossible to openly discuss the issue of the credibility of alleged “victims”. I have written before about how the Sisters of Mercy apologised to the accusers of Nora Wall and then failed to withdraw their apology (still less criticise the false accusers) when the case against her collapsed. [See my 2 Comments on “Funerals of Priests who are Out of Ministry”
https://www.associationofcatholicpriests.ie/2018/12/funerals-of-priests-who-are-out-of-ministry/ ]
Rory
I have no problem with managing expectations in general. But I do have difficulties managing expectations in silos.
We must also look at the totally innocent child that is also fed to the wolves and who is so innocent that he/she believes that the fault is of his/her own making.. it appears from your comments that you think the priest is more important than the child.. surely not?
By now we have all read Marie Collins recent post, she states in her message ” The Catholic Church is global and can be a force for good, raising the level of safety for all children by their example but they need to make a firm decision to bring this about.” We have seen more recently that the pope wishes to pursue policies that are clear to all ,globally.
So, let’s move out of our own particular silo and see that overall clear, transparent, codes of conduct and unambiguous consequences for breach of these codes along with the necessary prevention methods to help prevent child abuse in the first place will in fact benefit both the innocent priest and the totally innocent child/vulnerable adult.
Onwards and upwards – together; moving to a time when the only story the media can tell about the CC is the same one we talk about in Mass and other such gatherings of all the faithful. Moving to a time when the Church can stop wasting so much of peoples time and talents on irrelevant distractions such as sex and gender exclusions.. lets talk – adults to adults – its time..
Some devastating exposss about falsely accused priests have now surfaced in mainstream media:
http://thesestonewalls.com/gordon-macrae/fr-charles-engelhardt-the-lying-scheming-altar-boy-on-the-cover-of-newsweek/?fbclid=IwAR1DnI4dmvOiPCLOfd3gkybzUcMZvlqbZc-v5OUZE0gCcnlusbeBS2gU5fA
https://www.counterpunch.org/2016/02/29/oscar-hangover-special-why-spotlight-is-a-terrible-film
https://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2019/01/the-courageous-honesty-of-peter-steinfels