Hilda Geraghty: LISTENING TO UNBELIEVERS – for whom God is irrelevant.
One reason why faith today is not passing easily into younger generations is because the Church continues to present core dogmas in out-of-date concepts. Teilhard de Chardin felt this problem keenly in his own life and offered a new evolutionary vision to resolve this serious problem of credibility. Were the Church to adopt it, the faith would spread its cosmic wings and take off at supersonic speed!
“We don’t do God” was a throwaway remark by Alastair Campbell in 2003 in reference to the British Labour party. It sounds as if ‘doing God’ were some hobby or minority activity. Are we believers listening enough to these unbelievers?
No religion please, we’re British was the headline of an article in The Tablet,[1] in which the author commented that, in the recent debate on Assisted Dying in the House of Commons, any reference to a faith value was deemed ‘too sensitive to mention’.
‘It is now seen as archaic to hold Catholic values among the student body,’ said one teacher in a survey on bullying in Irish schools.[2]
These instances suggest that today in western Europe any reference to religion is becoming embarrassing. The person showing their faith may feel uncomfortable, and the listeners likewise. It has become harder to take a person of faith seriously, as if they are an anachronism of sorts, wearing the fashion of a bygone era. Religion is ‘old hat’.
EASY TO MISINTERPRET
It would be easy for believers to say that this is all part of the culture, that today’s ‘sinners’ have turned away from God, and need to convert, to discover the joy of a personal relationship with Jesus. Yet why are believing, practising parents finding it so hard to lead their children into this?
The latest document, Venite ad Me from the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith frankly admits that the Church is now unable to hand on the faith to its own new generations. The reasons are many, of course, but can we not learn more from people’s indifference or atheism? Young people are saying, in effect, that the faith we are offering leaves them indifferent. Can it really be taken seriously? Is it badly out of date? Are they abandoning a worn-out image of God?
NOT A NEW PROBLEM
One of the reasons why Pierre Teilhard de Chardin SJ (1881-1955) was such an original thinker within the Church was because, unlike most theologians, he spent most of his life among unbelievers, working as a scientist with and among them as an equal. I credit much of his Christian inspiration to this contact with unbelievers, to whom he listened carefully. He thought the Church needed to offer more to them, since they found belief tiresome in the way it continually deflected the energies of believers more to the next life than to this present one. This led Teilhard to develop the life-engaging spirituality of The Divine Milieu, where he invites Christians to meet God within the world through eyes of faith, to work for God’s glory in the world with the same passion that unbelievers brought to it. Why should the Christian faith make us somewhat less human? Christ came to bring life to the full.
Referencing Teilhard, the unique spiritual genius who drew faith and science into a single inspiring vision, American theologian John Haught, wrote in 2021,
‘Science’s great new discovery of a still emerging universe, however, is far from having become habitual to most Christian thinkers … Were Teilhard with us today, he would be saddened by the ongoing unresponsiveness of most Catholic thinkers to science … Given Christianity’s increasing irrelevance to the aspirations of countless scientifically educated people, the task seems more urgent than ever … Unfortunately, the relatively few Christian thinkers who have been rethinking their faith in a way that takes advantage of science are seldom taken seriously by the faithful at large, or by seminary instructors, or by religious officials.’[3]
SEPARATE WORLDS
Could this not be one reason why faith is not getting through to educated young minds today? Faith on the one hand, and human knowledge—science—on the other, are living in two separate ‘worlds’. People tend to live in the mental world that feels more comfortable. Faithful, educated Christians must learn to compartmentalise, rather than to integrate them. Catholicism still largely lives within its ivory tower, the religious culture of previous centuries. Is there a way to make its core theology newly credible?
It took the genius of Teilhard, with his spiritual-scientific horizons, to see the unified vision that religion needed to offer to remain relevant. He had created the scaffold for a great new building to house faith in Christ, a building that others would complete. Had he not been silenced by the head of his order in Rome, he would have opened up a whole new avenue of exploration for the faith among theologians. However, the Church held him back, out of fear of leading souls astray. Yet, like any other institution, fear can stultify the Church, dissuading it from adapting core dogmas in creative fidelity to both the past and the new understanding of the universe we live in. One result of this may be our emptier churches, where the weekly or daily celebration can seem irrelevant, unconnected to reality as we now know it.
THE NEW UNIVERSE STORY
So, having grasped that the universe, biological and human life is one universal story of becoming, of evolution, Teilhard saw that there were huge implications for the understanding of Christ. ‘This [realisation] is a major event which must lead us to radically change the whole structure of our Thought and our Beliefs.’[4] He began by focusing on one in particular.
The neuralgic point where faith and science clash is the doctrine of Original Sin, derived from a literal understanding of the Genesis Fall story, now incompatible with our knowledge of how the universe works. Attempting to help the Church into the modern world, Teilhard offered a new and credible interpretation of the Genesis Fall story: to see it as a true and freshly relevant portrait of human nature, chronically unwilling to listen to its conscience/voice of God in the drama of life. Treating myth, a sacred story, as an actual historical event remains a stranglehold preventing dogma transforming into something newly credible.
SALVATION NEWLY UNDERSTOOD
Were the Genesis story understood differently, the meaning of salvation could be magnificently renewed, freed from the supposed need to appease an offended God, above and beyond this world. The notion of a God whose forgiveness is linked to the exaction of a penalty is an imperial God who inspires fear. It overshadows the heart of the Christian faith as it continues to be celebrated. It does not warm the heart.
Moreover, this image does not align with the God of Abraham who expressly rejected a human sacrifice, nor with the God of Jesus as shown in the counter-intuitive parable of the Prodigal Son. The returning sinner finds that he is not judged and punished as anticipated, but warmly embraced by his father. The latter has no issue about injured honour. The son now belongs in the family again, and that he may later find penitential ways to make reparation is not the point.
Instead of the notion of paying a price to God, Christ’s death can be understood as the repairing of individual and collective relationships between self, others, world and God, brought about by Christ’s universal forgiveness from the cross. Given that God’s love, as shown by Jesus, is unconditional when we truly repent, God needs no reconciliation towards us sinners. It is only our repentance that is needed. “Repent and believe…” was the earliest message of the Gospel. Salvation, in this approach, is seen as the union in love of each and all in God and with each other, brought about by repentance-forgiveness, at all levels. “May they all be one in us,” as Jesus prayed at the Last Supper (Jn 17,21). Such a positive interpretation of salvation—as opposed to getting to heaven or escaping hell in the next life—would lift up hearts, inspiring them to tackle a very challenging world in the name of love.
NEWLY INSPIRED LANGUAGE
Much renewal is also needed in the language in which faith is expressed. It needs to be more richly inspired to reflect our present cosmic understanding of the universe. Christ needs to be acclaimed, in Teilhard’s terms, as the leader of evolution, the universal story of life on our planet, leading us towards unifying into a civilisation of love, centred on Omega, God. This God would no longer be simply ‘our Father who art in heaven’—never intended by Jesus to be the ultimate definition of God as an Old Man in the Sky. In Teilhard’s words,
“The God for whom our century is waiting must be:
-as vast and mysterious as the Cosmos
-as immediate and all-embracing as Life,
-connected to our effort as Humankind.
Any God who made the World less mysterious or smaller, or less important to us than our heart and our reason show it to be, that God—less beautiful than the God we await—will never more be the One to whom the earth kneels.”[5]
True faith has an excitement about it, a cry, “We have found the Messiah!” and quite a few have found it in Teilhard’s unifying vision. Haught again:
“Teilhard’s embrace of an unfinished and still-awakening universe is one of the main reasons why his writings mysteriously lift the hearts of his readers and make room for a new thrill of hope—an extensio animi ad magna [a stretching of the mind to great things]—that they had never experienced so palpably when reading and meditating on prescientific theological and spiritual works.” [6]
Teilhard uniquely gives cosmic robes to the role of Christ in an evolving universe, as the leader and centre of its process. Such a renewed image can once again capture the imagination—the place where faith is born, according to Doctor of the Church, St. John H. Newman.
GOING OUT TO THE WORLD
The latest Synod session in Rome called on the Church to look outwards to mission, but how is that to happen? The Church has to begin by being interested in where the world is at, where unbelievers of good will are at. Theology needs to leave its ivory tower, professionally interest itself in science, and to incorporate the findings of science into its dogmas, insofar as it affects them. And affect them it does, because the culture in which they were originally formulated has changed out of all recognition. Where faith and human knowledge—science—fail to mutually nourish each other, it is faith that loses out badly. Speaking of humanity’s passion for knowledge, Teilhard makes a heartfelt plea to the Church:
“Accept it, this sap—for without its baptism, you will wither from lack of desire, like a flower out of water; and tend this sap, since from lack of your sun, it will grow wild in sterile shoots.” [7]
CAN WE LISTEN?
This prophetic warning has yet to be heeded. Not every corner of the Church welcomed Pope Francis’ urgent call to take care of the earth—‘What has this got to do with religion?’ they wondered. The Church would greatly help its mission by acclaiming the treasure it has in Teilhard de Chardin, its faithful prophet silenced for a lifetime. When friends published his writings after his death, a monitum[to be read with caution], was placed on them, a warning still to be lifted by the Vatican. Were his reputation in the Church to be fully restored, it would give theology exciting new inspiration, enabling it to speak more meaningfully to the people of today and tomorrow.
Teilhard’s thinking is quietly gaining ground. His vision of the whole deeply inspired the American, Thomas Berry, to initiate the now worldwide ecological movement. Berry is quoted by cosmologist, Brian Swimme, as telling him, ‘To see as Teilhard saw is a challenge, but increasingly his vision is becoming available to us. I fully expect that in the next millennium Teilhard will be generally regarded as the fourth major thinker of the western Christian tradition. These would be St Paul, Augustine, Thomas Aquinas and Teilhard.’[8]
As things stand, there is talk of a turn of young people towards the Christian faith again, tired of a superficial culture. If they come knocking at the Church’s door, what will they find if they ask the really deep questions?
CONCLUSION
The Church’s presentation of some core dogmas is seriously out of date, out of touch with today’s world and its horizon-shattering discoveries. It is offering ‘too small a Christ’, to use Teilhard’s expression, and too small a God, speaking out of a worldview too small for educated people of today. This is one reason why it can be embarrassing to be a believer, perceived as still living in a mindset of the past.
Let us hope that having elevated St John Henry Newman to Doctor, the Church will open doors toa creative redevelopment of core dogmas. We need a new St Paul for a new epoch. Could he not be Teilhard de Chardin, faithfully recasting the Church’s teaching into terms that could speak to today’s ‘Gentiles’. This wouldleavebelievers no longer embarrassed about their faith, but confident, enthused and inspired.
Hilda Geraghty is a retired secondary school teacher, living in Dublin and a member of the Teresian Association.
Her website: www.teilharddechardinforall.com
[2]The Furrow, December 2021, Difficult times for Catholic students in second Level Schools? The voices of RE teachers. p 698.
[3]The Cosmic Vision of Teilhard de Chardin, John A. Haught, p.13 Orbis Books, Maryknoll, New York 2021.
[4]The Future of Man, Collins, Fontana Books, 1969, a collection of essays grouped under this theme.
[5]The Heart of Matter, p 212.
[6]The Cosmic Vision of Teilhard de Chardin by John F. Haught. 2021. P 32, Orbis Books, Maryknoll, New York.
[7]The Divine Milieu. Harper Torchbooks p 154, Harper and Row, Publishers New York 1965
[8]The Human Phenomenon,p xiv, a new edition and translation, Sussex Academic Press, Brighton, Chicago, Toronto, 2015.

The divine milieu is ever new, ever to be explored. Many feel that the impossibly vast cosmos is an anti-divine force, yet two aspects of it send us back to meaning and mystery: its intelligibility to the human scientific mind and its aesthetic impact on the heart. To move in that milieu today we should open up anew to the biblical and Christian witnesses who speak from eternity, Paul, John, Augustine, Newman, Thérèse, reading them with our hearts and imaginations. Pope Francis told the Thomistic congress at Rome a few years ago: “Read St Thomas contemplatively, not casuistically.” (Has he become the problem child of Christian theology?) Pope Francis also pointed further — to contemplative encounter with the symphony of religions, all of which are paths to the divine, and (as a disciple of Romano Guardini) to the world of literature, which has undergone a singular evolution in the modern age, both reflecting and bringing about changes in human nature itself. I was surprised to rediscover T. S. Eliot yesterday, thanks to a BBC documentary by A. N. Wilson, who showed how his verse gets to the nerve center of modernity and speaks of Christ there, in open, vulnerable, questioning dialogue with Buddhism and Hinduism.
Link for A. N. Wilson: https://wingspanproductions.com/what-we-do/read/51/Return-to-T-S-Eliotland
Four Quartets remains a significant poem for the spiritual life of humanity, but especially for the Church of England, Eliot’s spiritual home. Rowan Williams lectured on it in 1975 and has talked of a book on it.
file:///C:/Users/joe32/Desktop/motalamz,+3388-17129-1-CE+SHE+proof+Towards+a+Visionary+Delport+23Jan2017%20(2).pdf
Serious attention to Eliot’s interreligious culture (already in The Waste Land) is key to taking him out from under a provincial bushel.