Paddy O’Kane (Derry) on the AGM

Association of Irish Priests
Two weeks ago I attended the newly formed Association of Irish Priests in Dublin together with priests from religious orders and dioceses all over the country. It was an invigorating experience to be there in a room full of people passionate about their church. We shared our hopes and dreams, our heartbreaks and sadness for our beloved Irish Church.
After a prayer to the Holy Spirit, Fr. Bernard Hoban began on Tuesday evening. He explained the history of the Association and reviewed the last year. Fr. Kevin Hegarty addressed us in a speech full of poetry and wit. Please read it on the website: www.associationofcatholicpriests.ie. On Wednesday morning after the re-election of officers the floor was opened to the priests in a listening exercise. Topics offered for discussion were the election of bishops, the Eucharistic Congress, crisis in ministry, married priests, how allegations of child abuse are handled- though we did not have to limit ourselves to these. The mid-day session was conducted by Marie Keenan on her new book on child abuse within the Catholic Church in Ireland followed by an open and frank open floor discussion.
It was good to be there not least because of the freedom to ask honest, soul searching questions about the association and those who are in leadership of the church at this time .There is no other forum like it and similar associations are sprouting up all over the world. Ordinary priests whether in parishes or the missions feel they have no voice and, as they are at the coal face between the laity and official church, they have an important contribution to make .
To the best of my memory this is roughly my contribution to that debate:
‘’Let us take accept that the ‘dead horse has been truly flogged’ once and for all. Otherwise we can go on forever moaning about the mistakes of the past. Let us look to the future, have a vision and even offer some constructive proposals.
These are worthwhile issues offered for discussion [see above]and we can make resolution after resolution all day long but to no avail unless we step back and ask a more fundamental question namely ‘ How do we engage with those who refuse to listen?’ The bishops are a frightened bunch and will only circle their wagons even tighter together if they feel that this Association is the attacking Indians and a threat. From my observation of the workings of the Priests Council at home the greater the trust the more open the dialogue. ‘Argument ad Hominum ’was taught to us in my first year in Maynooth in 1966 as no. 7 in a list of Common Logical Errors. It means that is not so much the message but the messengers that people react to and so the message is often dismissed. I do not know the answer to this problem but it must be faced. We have to work with the bishops –otherwise you have to form an alternative church .Many of them may be more sympathetic to this association and its aims than we are willing to admit. Why not ask them to nominate someone for co –option on to the board of the association? This is only an example of the way I am thinking so we move into meaningful dialogue and away from an ‘us and them ‘situation. Yes, let us listen to what the Spirit is saying to all the People of God, debate it openly and ask for change. But let us help those whom we want to hear what we are saying to listen as well. When I told a priest back home in Derry I was coming to this meeting he asked me ‘what are you doing getting involved with that bunch of soreheads?
Some rejected my suggestion as playing politics while others agreed with me and shared that they too had my experience of how the association was viewed. ‘What are you doing going up to Dublin the to the Hoban- Flannery show?’ one priest told us he was asked by his fellow priests. My fear is that the association may be dismissed by many Irish priests and bishops as a bunch of cranks or as ‘nobodies representing nobodies’ as a Papal Nuncio once described a similar priests’ group. But then Christ too was probably dismissed by many as a ‘sorehead’ and as a ‘nobody from Nazareth’.
I met four interesting priests there but unfortunately I have run out of space.
I’ll tell you more about them next week.

Similar Posts


  1. Sean (Derry) says:

    Great news to hear that only four Derry priests are members of ACP. May God Bless St. Columba.

  2. Depresssing to hear the proposal that Bishops should be part of the leadership time. It would be the kiss of death for the ACP. What can’t we as priests rightly claim our own space and speak our own truth besides always feeling we must keep the bishops on side. We need to work alongside them surely but we need to do this while still retaining our own platform.
    The Bishops don’t feel any need to have PP’s and indeed CC’s represented at the Bishops Conferences- Let us hold the independent voice we have now established.
    The ACP have done a great service to the priests of Ireland- as seen in the Kevin Reynolds case. Bishops joining might see the number of clergy from other dioceses, where numbers are significantly higher, drop to match the Derry 4! Let’s not forget the lessons of the NCPI.

  3. Eddie Finnegan says:

    Sean (Derry), don’t crow! Columba was hardly a unifying paragon himself in his time. Didn’t he start a bloody war because of his lack of respect for Finnian’s copyright? Maybe he thought, like many a Derryman, that a few years of peace-processing on Iona would qualify him as Ard Rí.
    But Fr Paddy O’Kane helpfully reminds me of Matt O’Donnell’s warning against the ‘Argumentum ad hominem’, so I’ll leave Columba to pray for Sean (Derry) or vice versa.
    Rather than inviting bishops to nominate one of their number to the ACP leadership, why not encourage your local ordinary to ‘drop in’ to the local branch meeting of the ACP and behave as one among equals among the ordinary locals? If +Liam McDaid can do that in Clogher, I’m sure +Seamus Hegarty could make himself at home among the Derry Four and maybe even help to get the rest of the Derry ditherers to join you?

  4. Sean (Derry) says:

    Eddie Finnegan, yes good old St. Columba, just goes to show, “Every saint has a past and every sinner has a future”, so maybe there is still hope for all of us (even ACP members).
    BTW, the Long Tower Church in Derry (St. Columba’s), has just announced a regular Latin Mass on the first Sunday of each month (starting this Sunday).
    God Bless Saint Columba.

  5. That’s great Sean, but I wish it would become more than just a monthly treat – the powers that be need to see that the needs of the faithful are met. The Holy Father clearly wants the EF Mass offered widely and freely, and once a month on a Sunday doesn’t cut it. I am not having a go at you, but once a month is hardly enough that it could become a habit! Vent over.

  6. Dead Horse? We are the Resurrected body of Christ!

Join the Discussion

Keep the following in mind when writing a comment

  • Your comment must include your full name, and email. (email will not be published). You may be contacted by email, and it is possible you might be requested to supply your postal address to verify your identity.
  • Be respectful. Do not attack the writer. Take on the idea, not the messenger. Comments containing vulgarities, personalised insults, slanders or accusations shall be deleted.
  • Keep to the point. Deliberate digressions don't aid the discussion.
  • Including multiple links or coding in your comment will increase the chances of it being automati cally marked as spam.
  • Posts that are merely links to other sites or lengthy quotes may not be published.
  • Brevity. Like homilies keep you comments as short as possible; continued repetitions of a point over various threads will not be published.
  • The decision to publish or not publish a comment is made by the site editor. It will not be possible to reply individually to those whose comments are not published.