Sean O’Conaill calls for clarity on the meaning of the Cross
The Irish Times, Original Sin and the Gospel
From the Irish Times of Saturday 14 Nov 2026 – Patsy McGarry interviewing former Irish President Mary McAleese on the occasion of her latest book, challenging Catholic Canon Law on infant Baptism:
‘The theology behind Baptism – rooted in the original sin of Adam and Eve who, in disobeying God, precipitated the death of Jesus so God might forgive humanity – “needs to be looked at again”, she [MMcA] says. “I leave it to others, because I believe that’s a very, very big subject that demands another book or set of books.”’
(‘Mary McAleese on baptism, women’s ordination, and a ‘savage’ GAA experience’ – Irish Times 14 Nov 2026)
Patsy McGarry’s highly compressed and simplistic account of ‘the theology behind Baptism’ mistakenly implies that only one theological explanation of the crucifixion of Jesus has ever been offered by the Catholic church.
However, given that this account is indeed one way of understanding the Crucifixion, will any Irish Catholic authority take this opportunity to offer an alternative understanding – one that does not attribute to God the Father a demand that Jesus suffer crucifixion to win his own forgiveness?
As the US contemplative Richard Rohr OFM has been insisting for decades that the Franciscan theological tradition never accepted that God the Father ever needed to be persuaded to forgive us – and that theologians such as Duns Scotus argued that from the beginning the Incarnation had been planned and intended by Him – this surely needs to be more widely understood?
More recently, in arguing that the Gospel reveals the cultural pattern of scapegoating – the accusation and elimination of an innocent victim to release social tension and stabilise an existing social order – the anthropologist and philosopher René Girard has inspired the dramatic theology of Raymund Schwager SJ. In this understanding Jesus suffered crucifixion to protest not only this victimisation of the innocent but to reveal the root of all violence in our aboriginal problem of mimetic desire, i.e. what the bible calls our ‘covetousness’.
Called now to proclaim the Gospel should we not be officially encouraged to believe that from the beginning God the Father foresaw our waywardness, made us radically imitative and planned to show us whom to imitate?
If on the other hand, we Irish Catholics are now to be dependent upon the Irish Times to inform us on the Catholic theology of Original Sin and the Crucifixion are we not in the deepest possible trouble?

St Patrick, for one, never referred to any need of God the Father for an atoning sacrifice. The satisfaction theory most commonly associated with St Anselm of Canterbury did not emerge until the late eleventh century.
Instead, the dominant theme of Patrick’s surviving writings is Christ as victor over every danger and hostile power. The Breastplate prayer stands firmly within the patristic tradition often described as ‘Christus Victor’: the understanding that in Christ’s death and resurrection God intended from the beginning to liberate humanity from the power of sin, evil and death itself.
As Ireland’s synodal pathway is fundamentally missionary, should we not recover this older and more hopeful proclamation? For many people today, the central question is not how God could be persuaded to forgive us, but whether God is indeed for us and with us in a world still shadowed by fear, violence and death.
How can synodal renewal be advanced by a theology that appears to set the Son’s mercy against the Father’s justice, when the Gospel of John repeatedly emphasises their unity of purpose and love? As Jesus insists: “I and the Father are one” (John 10:30). The Gospel surely presents not a reluctant Father being persuaded by a compassionate Son, but a Father whose love is revealed in and through the Son?