Comments

All recent Comments

  • “There is a battle going on within the Irish Catholic Church at the moment.”

    May 20 2015
    Mary Vallely

    "Fear, greed and pride are at work here, and must be resisted. If we fear one another so much that we compulsively conceal our sexuality and present a false front to our neighbour, or are unable to ac

    Read more 14 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    Prodigal Son

    We in the Catholic Church are now truly separated from the state, and will come under more pressure down the road. Thank God. Thank you also to the bishops who opposed the redefinition of marriage.

    Read more 30 comments
  • “There is a battle going on within the Irish Catholic Church at the moment.”

    May 20 2015
    Nuala O'Driscoll

    @ 11 'Condemnations are more suited to media headlines'...But Padraig it is exactly the anathemas, the condemnations, the exclusions, the silencings the punishments that has done irreparable damage to

    Read more 14 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    Joe O'Leary

    We are so used to being bullied by stupidity from prelates that the insulting remarks of the Vatican Secretary of State will probably go unreprimanded. One Italian commentator on a Facebook thread see

    Read more 30 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    Joe O'Leary

    Is it not true that the Church regards all civil marriages as dissoluble in favour of the faith if one of the spouses wants to marry a Catholic?

    Read more 30 comments
  • “There is a battle going on within the Irish Catholic Church at the moment.”

    May 20 2015
    Joe O'Leary

    The Vatican document Homosexualitatis Problema received strong condemnation from two Irish priests, Bernard Lynch and myself, just after its publication. It is still proudly displayed on the Vatican w

    Read more 14 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    JimK

    Padraig McCarthy@11 is correct, my mistake, the church does recognise civil marriages between two non-Catholics as valid. Thanks for spotting the error. I suppose the point I was trying to make is tha

    Read more 30 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    Pádraig McCarthy

    There's an overview of Constitutional provisions of various European countries, and of some European and International Law, at https://www.academia.edu/12599627/European_and_International_Comparative_

    Read more 30 comments
  • “There is a battle going on within the Irish Catholic Church at the moment.”

    May 20 2015
    Pádraig McCarthy

    Mícheál @ 10: I think condemnation can be counter-productive: it can make a person become defensive and closed. Condemnations are more suited to media headlines, and can serve to draw more attention

    Read more 14 comments
  • The people have spoken …

    May 25 2015
    Joe O'Leary

    "Selfconfessed" illustrates what Mrs McAleese referred to as the needless suffering and loneliness of young gays, for which coy clerical silence bears considerable blame. The message sent by the refer

    Read more 30 comments

Categories