Gerard Flynn,
I wonder what you mean when you refer to my "traditionalist views"? Terms such as "traditionalist" and "progressive" carry little meaning in theological debate. Use of such terms tend to
Eamon Keane,
Exactly how will the new interlinear 'translation' bring the Trinitarian dimension of the Eucharist into sharper focus? You've made your traditionalist views quite clear on this blog befo
Grammar and syntax are not that important to you, if your own contribution is anything to go by.
It's not surprising therefore, that you don't have any problems with the new translation.
I feel that I must reply to this comment by Father Hoban, I think the easiest way to do so is, in the manner of the original article, point by point.
1)I must I’m a layman and I’ve heard about thi
Good point why are the bishops accepting this if they disagree or is it just another case of them fudging the issue and trying to be friends with all. Leadership is needed here not mixed messages or m
Bishops
I see Fr Hoban in his tirade mentions that "some bishops" have problems with rhe new translation. Why are they introducing it then? Have they any courage whatsoever? Will these men who have be
This is dreadful stuff. Narrow-minded priests running around fighting about where the deck chairs should be placed while all around them the ship is sinking and laypeople are taking to the lifeboats.
Comments
All recent Comments
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011Gerard Flynn, I wonder what you mean when you refer to my "traditionalist views"? Terms such as "traditionalist" and "progressive" carry little meaning in theological debate. Use of such terms tend to
Theologian criticises ACP’s absence at liturgical conference
August 4 2011John Smith describes a contemporary person as a 'patristic' scholar. It looks like the faux pas that only someone in Rome could make.
Theologian criticises ACP’s absence at liturgical conference
August 4 2011Eddie, In the best possible media jargon . no comment! I wonder who John Smith is. He has been very active in two postings about the conference.
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011@Mary Burke Yes Mary, ignore the issues raised and attack me instead, that's the way to win an argument and make me change my mind.
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011Eamon Keane, Exactly how will the new interlinear 'translation' bring the Trinitarian dimension of the Eucharist into sharper focus? You've made your traditionalist views quite clear on this blog befo
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011Grammar and syntax are not that important to you, if your own contribution is anything to go by. It's not surprising therefore, that you don't have any problems with the new translation.
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011I feel that I must reply to this comment by Father Hoban, I think the easiest way to do so is, in the manner of the original article, point by point. 1)I must I’m a layman and I’ve heard about thi
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011Good point why are the bishops accepting this if they disagree or is it just another case of them fudging the issue and trying to be friends with all. Leadership is needed here not mixed messages or m
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011Bishops I see Fr Hoban in his tirade mentions that "some bishops" have problems with rhe new translation. Why are they introducing it then? Have they any courage whatsoever? Will these men who have be
Response to Vincent Twomey by Brendan Hoban
August 5 2011This is dreadful stuff. Narrow-minded priests running around fighting about where the deck chairs should be placed while all around them the ship is sinking and laypeople are taking to the lifeboats.
Popular Posts
Categories