Martin, the SSPX used to celebrate according to the pre-Pius XII form in its early days. Marcel Lefebvre ordered his priests as of Easter 1984 to celebrate the 1962 Missal - the last pre-conciliar edi
Shane, if the 1962 Missal is good enough for the SSPX, then it's good enough for me. I say that tongue in cheek. But, correct me if I am wrong, the SSPX are OK with the 1962 Missal. Are you more tradi
Martin I hope by the Traditional Latin Mass ("TLM") you do not mean the Roman Missal of 1962 --- which by no stretch of the imagination could be considered 'traditional'. At best it is an earlier ele
"The thing is, anything produced by a committee is going to be a compromise."
The new translations are more than a compromise. They are an insult --- both to God and to the worshipping community.
Th
The thing is, anything produced by a committee is going to be a compromise. Years ago, the Adoremus Society produced a very nice translation, but it was ignored.
This translation may not be perfect,
Thank you, Padraig, for your comments. I appreciate your giving your opinion, - and echo itC4.
I note that the Bishops' statement provides no response whatever to any of the serious issues raised in
It is not the laity only that will not understand the new texts. I am unable to understand the Preface for the Feast of the Holy Trinity:
"For with your Only Begotten Son and the Holy Spirit
you are
What have you got in mind Annette? Stay and be a good Catholic or found your own sect? Be as handy to join one of the existing ones. I'd never encourage anyone to leave the Catholic Church, but if you
Comments
All recent Comments
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011Martin, the SSPX used to celebrate according to the pre-Pius XII form in its early days. Marcel Lefebvre ordered his priests as of Easter 1984 to celebrate the 1962 Missal - the last pre-conciliar edi
19 June Sunday Feast of The Most Holy Trinity
June 19 2011Am I correct in thinking that this second reading should be from the second letter to the Corinthians rather than the first as above?
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011Shane, if the 1962 Missal is good enough for the SSPX, then it's good enough for me. I say that tongue in cheek. But, correct me if I am wrong, the SSPX are OK with the 1962 Missal. Are you more tradi
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011Martin I hope by the Traditional Latin Mass ("TLM") you do not mean the Roman Missal of 1962 --- which by no stretch of the imagination could be considered 'traditional'. At best it is an earlier ele
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011Seen the latest on Fr. Corapi? Off-topic I know but interesting all the same: http://www.fathercorapi.com/default.aspx
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011"The thing is, anything produced by a committee is going to be a compromise." The new translations are more than a compromise. They are an insult --- both to God and to the worshipping community. Th
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011The thing is, anything produced by a committee is going to be a compromise. Years ago, the Adoremus Society produced a very nice translation, but it was ignored. This translation may not be perfect,
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011Thank you, Padraig, for your comments. I appreciate your giving your opinion, - and echo itC4. I note that the Bishops' statement provides no response whatever to any of the serious issues raised in
Padraig McCarthy responding to Bishop’s latest statement on New Missal
June 16 2011It is not the laity only that will not understand the new texts. I am unable to understand the Preface for the Feast of the Holy Trinity: "For with your Only Begotten Son and the Holy Spirit you are
Text of Address by Angela Hanley
June 14 2011What have you got in mind Annette? Stay and be a good Catholic or found your own sect? Be as handy to join one of the existing ones. I'd never encourage anyone to leave the Catholic Church, but if you
Popular Posts
Categories