Comments

All recent Comments

  • Which way for the church?

    February 9 2019
    Paddy Ferry

    Like Mary I was intrigued by Fr. O'Malley's explanation in "What happened at Vatican II" of how the Council was also a "language event" and how the previous model of longitudinal language --top down -

    Read more 3 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    # 9, 10, 11 It is not the language of the Bible that is the problem, Joe. The problem is the interpretation of those passages by way of satisfactionism and substitutionalism - which originate the vio

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    A lot of what the Fathers write on the Atonement is quaint and outdated, but their strong point is the rootedness of their discourse in deep reflection on the Incarnation. Greek philosophy helped them

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    There have been bad theologies of the Atonement, such as the devil's ransom theory, but of course the discourse of the Fathers is much richer and more joyful than this. Athanasius writes (On the In

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    Sean, I know that the Feast of the Precious Blood has been whisked away, but the language of being "saved by his blood" is still very central in Christian tradition and piety. Consider, "Blood of my S

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    #7 First, Joe, the expression 'saved by his blood', has absolutely no 'power' for very many people today. Secondly, Girard attributes the loss of this 'pulling power' of 'blood sacrifice' to the Cruc

    Read more 38 comments
  • The Cult of Clericalism – we look after ourselves

    February 1 2019
    Darlene Starrs

    Eugene, you have presented the next most urgent question of the day...Do we require an ordained priesthood?...Here we must find a courageous and insightful theologian or theologians who are willing t

    Read more 11 comments
  • The Quiet Revolution – A Talk by Gerry O’ Hanlon

    February 12 2019
    Pascal O'Dea

    ACI Association of Catholics in Ireland welcome people to our meeting to hear FrGerry O'Hanlon talk on his recent book.Bishop Denis Nulty Kildare and leiglin will attend and it offers an opportunity f

    Read more 1 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    "He was delivered over to death for our sins and was raised to life for our justification"(Rom 4:25) Since Paul is using the "theological passive" it can also be translated "God delivered him over to

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O’Conaill

    Missing here, as usual, is Rene Girard’s anthropological proposal that the crucifixion of Jesus is above all a revelation of the aboriginal sin of scapegoating - the human practice of defusing a soc

    Read more 38 comments

Categories