Comments

All recent Comments

  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Paddy Ferry

    Joe, I cannot find the article where I got the impression--mistakenly, I now accept --that Pell had dropped his appeal. There has been so much written about this but I do remember that it was the same

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Frances Burke

    This is difficult viewing but it gives a good overview on the Cardinal Pell case. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EHBAyP2wjic

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Eddie Finnegan1

    The virtual mob lacks two virtues of the real street mob: the latter works off its fury with a bit of exercise and fresh air. Seems to me George Pell deserves his appeal and perhaps a better defence l

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Mary Burke

    The article by Rita Ferrone on Vox Clara: https://www.commonwealmagazine.org/revisiting-liturgiam-authenticam-part-i-vox-clara

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    Correction, the second trial did NOT include live evidence from the complainant but only a video of his evidence at the earlier trial. Correct story is here: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-ne

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    Doubt grows.... https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/blogs/andrew-bolt/pell-case-more-doubters-come-forward/news-story/4f594f60d59dbb90c230143e93a2683c I see one commenter draws the Dreyfus analogy: "

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    Paddy, I think you confused his abandonment of an application for bail with abandonment of the appeal. The former is mentioned here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZtoUNNBQHxQ Pell has virtues of pl

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    As everyone is saying, the process is not complete until the appeal. See https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-03-03/pell-case-needs-appeals-court-hearing-before-judgement-church/10865634 Pell is very unp

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Mary Burke

    In this 2017 article from Commonweal, entitled 'Revisiting Ligurgiam Authenticam. Part 1. Vox Clara, Rita Ferrone makes the following devastating comment: (Interestingly Ferrone's money is on Father A

    Read more 60 comments
  • Fine words and dramatic gestures are not enough!

    February 19 2019
    Paddy Ferry

    Joe, you said at the beginning of this that we had to let due process take it's course. Now, that process is complete and Pell has been found guilty. So, why can you not accept that. I read during t

    Read more 60 comments

Categories