Comments

All recent Comments

  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    #21 There was nothing violent about Jesus's acceptance of the cross - a truth that became seriously obscured with Contantine in 312 - indeed almost suppressed but for the Gospel record. Hence the sca

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Paddy Ferry

    Thanks, Sean and Joe, for that additional information. I have to say I find it absolutely extraordinary that a great scholar of the calibre of Girard, who obviously would have studied this matter at g

    Read more 38 comments
  • A prayer on the occasion of the Vatican Summit on abuse in the church

    February 16 2019
    Dermot Healy

    Excellent prayer. Thank you very much

    Read more 3 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    I might have been the first one to challenge Girard's statements in a conversation with him when the book was hot from the press in 1978! By the way the ransom theory does not mean that a debt was pa

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    #16 Re that statement of Girard in 'Things Hidden' (1978) - denying that the passion story should be seen as narrating a 'sacrifice' - with my own ears I heard René Girard in 2004 in Heythrop Colleg

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    On the Blood of Christ, I am looking just now at the publications I mentioned earlier by the Centro Studi Sanguis Christi, Rome 1981-1991. (I, II, and VII are in Sophia University library)). The volum

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Joe O'Leary

    Paddy, I remember that book, which is full of such sweeping and inaccurate statements from Girard. It's a set of improvised interviews he gave to two admiring disciples vying in mimetic rivalry for hi

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Paddy Ferry

    Joe and Sean, what a wonderful conversation we have had from you all this week on the nature of the sacrificial death, or otherwise, of Jesus, which I may have been responsible for setting off last Su

    Read more 38 comments
  • 10 February. 5th Sunday (C)

    February 10 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    #13 Who is arguing that to abandon satisfactionalism is to undermine the ethic of sacrifice? Time and again I have argued here that an understanding of the crucifixion as a revelation of the scapegoa

    Read more 38 comments
  • Sexuality – a church’s need to learn as well as teach

    February 15 2019
    Sean O'Conaill

    This article is a courageous exception to the rule that seems to govern clerical behaviour in the Irish Church re sexuality: 'Don't ever go there!' The unfortunate result is that it is left - almost

    Read more 1 comments

Categories